Rivers Coalition Meeting November 21, 2024

November 26, 2024

The November 21 Rivers Coalition meeting focused on Major Cory Bell from the Army Corps of Engineers sharing the reasoning behind their decision to start releasing water from Lake Okeechobee into the St. Lucie Estuary on December 7 in a “Lake Recovery Operation”.


Why now? Four years of above-normal lake levels have destroyed almost 90% of the lake’s submerged aquatic vegetation – the grass that’s needed for the little critters at the bottom of the food chain to grow and for bass to spawn. During that time, the lake’s turgidity has degraded so much that sunlight, essential to plant growth, can only penetrate three feet of lake water compared to the six feet that was previously the case. The Lake Recovery Operation’s plan is to lower the current lake level (16.03 feet; a foot above the late-November optimal management level) to 12 feet or less for a 90-day period. They want to reach that 12-foot level on May 1, to allow the decimated submerged aquatic vegetation beds to recover during the summer.


It sounds like a wonderful idea. Alas, there’s a cost – a big one, to us. The Lake Recovery Operation would send a whole lot of fresh water down to the St. Lucie Estuary. As the Florida Oceanographic Society noted in a letter to the Corps, “Over the past two months, the St. Lucie Estuary has been subjected to prolonged freshwater conditions as a result of sustained stormwater runoff. This influx of fresh water has devastated essential marine ecosystems, including the widespread loss of oysters and seagrass beds, already suffering from the effects from recent rainfall runoff.” They added: “Any further freshwater introduction from USACE operations could hinder or even halt the potential for recovery of the estuary.” 


Simply put: What’s good for the lake is bad for the estuary. 


You will probably not be surprised that Rivers Coalition members were not at all happy with the Lake Recovery Operation.   


The FOS and Friends of the Everglades have both written the Corps urging them to reconsider the timing and scope of their Lake Recovery Operations. If you’d like to join them, you can send an email to cory.j.bell@usace.army.mil .


Meanwhile, a frustrated Jacqui Thurlow-Lippisch observed that the Treasure Coast’s position on the South Florida Water Management District’s Board has remained unfilled ever since the Florida Senate refused to consider her reappointment two years ago. She urged us to try to get the Governor to appoint somebody – anybody – to advocate for the Treasure Coast on the so-important-to-us SFWMD board. So if you happen to bump into the Governor… 


February 2, 2026
The featured presenter at the January 22nd Rivers Coalition meeting was Army Corps of Engineers Jacksonville District Commander Col. Brandon Bowman. He reported: * The Lake Okeechobee management effort is going well. The lake level is currently a near-ideal 13.01 feet. In addition, following last summer’s Lake Recovery Operation, Submerged Aquatic Vegetation (“sea grass”) now covers 20,000 acres of the lake bottom compared with just 3000 acres beforehand. * All stakeholders but one are having their needs met at the present time: The Caloosahatchee River west of the lake isn’t receiving nearly as much fresh water as it needs. * The biggest threat to the St. Lucie Estuary right now isn’t discharges from Lake Okeechobee; it’s polluted runoff flowing into the headwaters of the North Fork. The Corps has several projects underway to address that issue. * The Everglades restoration effort continues moving forward, albeit at a seemingly-glacial pace. To wit: Col. Bowman was happy to announce that the Everglades Agricultural Area projects would be completed five years ahead of schedule – but that still won’t be until the end of 2029. * The big C-44 Reservoir, just north of the St. Lucie Canal in western Martin County, is a key part of the management plan. The reservoir will store runoff and remove phosphorus before discharging the water. Unfortunately, it hasn’t been able to operate at capacity; there’s a seepage issue at one end, and it can only be filled to ten feet compared with its designed fifteen-foot level. The Corps doesn’t think the reservoir will be able to be filled to capacity until 2032. * Finally, Coalition members expressed a great deal of alarm about the Corps’ Engineering Research and Development Center’s plan to develop treatments to remove peroxide and phosphorus from the water. The concern stems from the ERDC’s need to test those treatments, and they have to do the testing in the St. Lucie Canal. There was widespread fear that this could produce harmful results in our canal and our estuary. On the legislative front, Gil Smart, the Friends of the Everglades monitor of the goings-on in Tallahassee, shook his head: “If last year’s legislative session’s theme was facilitating sprawl, this year’s is sprawl on steroids.” A disturbingly large number of bills have been filed that will allow more and more development projects to be subject only to administrative approval rather than, as now, being required to go through a public review process. If these bills pass they will drastically reduce public input on some very big and impactful development proposals -- and completely eliminate it in some cases. As these and other really bad bills get rammed towards the finish line, you will undoubtably be receiving calls for action from your favorite environmental organization. Keep an eye on your inbox. -- Walter Deemer, LWVMC Rivers Coalition Representative
September 28, 2025
The body content of your post goes here. To edit this text, click on it and delete this default text and start typing your own or paste your own from a different source.
September 1, 2025